A 2022 systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized, controlled trials of various interventions with and without surgery for non-fracture musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions in adults evaluated the potential benefits and harms.1 One hundred randomized, controlled trials involving a total of 12,645 patients were selected, representing 28 different conditions at nine body sites including the neck, low back, shoulder, pelvis, hip and knee.
Except for certain spinal conditions (see below), pain data on nine of 13 conditions, function data on 11 of 11 conditions and quality-of-life data on nine of nine conditions found no clinically relevant differences between interventions with and without surgery. For serious adverse events (SAEs), 13 of 16 conditions with data; and for death, 16 of 16 conditions, found no differences in harms between surgery vs. no surgery.
Of the remaining four of 13 conditions with pain data, surgery appeared to lead to a greater improvement of at least moderate effect size for cervical disc herniation (three studies), lumbar spinal stenosis (five studies), sacroiliac joint pain (two studies), and chronic low back pain (five studies) – but did not demonstrate greater improvement in either function or quality of life.
In addition, only 14 percent of MSK RCTs comparing surgery to placebo surgery, nonsurgical intervention or no intervention demonstrated statistically significant and clinically relevant benefits for surgery.
This isn't the first time research has suggested most musculoskeletal conditions should be treated nonsurgically. Per a 2021 study, "The low certainty of evidence does not support recommending surgery over nonsurgical alternatives for most MSK conditions with available RCTs."2
A previous systematic review also suggested MSK surgeries have fewer supporting RCTs compared to other surgical procedures, and that less than 1 percent compared surgery to not performing the surgical procedure.3
And the authors of a 2017 study stated, "[F]or many conditions, best practice nonsurgical interventions are viable alternatives to surgery. Even for patients where nonsurgical treatment is not sufficiently effective, evidence supporting the effects of surgery is missing. For some conditions, surgery is even recommended against by clinical guidelines and does not provide additional benefit to nonsurgical treatment."4
Even after surgery, the costs5 and need for further nonsurgical care6-7 can be high, suggesting that undergoing successful surgery in terms of improved pain and function is not necessarily associated with reduced societal burden of MSK conditions; or does not necessarily result in the surgical intervention being more cost-effective as an alternative or in addition to nonsurgical intervention.6,8
These results, when combined with previous research, further support nonsurgical interventions as first-line care for MSK conditions for pain reduction, increased physical function, improved quality of life and fewer serious adverse events.
References
Structured water (H3O2) can be considered a fourth state of water between liquid and solid. It has the hexagonal structure of ice; however, missing a critical bond, it behaves more like a gel than a solid, but retains some of its crystalline structure.
In the past five years of my clinical practice, I have seen an astonishing upsurge in the chronic use of proton-pump inhibitor (PPI) medications for the gastrointestinal issue diagnosed by allopathic medicine as GERD. It is not uncommon to encounter patients taking these prescriptions for five-plus years.
Working with chronically ill patients entails acknowledging the reality that not all patients will survive their diagnosis. Chinese medicine and acupuncture play a crucial role in palliative and end-of-life care, addressing medication and disease side effects, alleviating pain associated with death, reducing anxiety and stress, and helping patients find peace during the dying process.
